Saturday, October 19, 2019

Chief Judge Peter Kidd must explain why he chose to speak on national TV: What did the judge hope to achieve on TV which he could not achieve via his decisions?

by Ganesh Sahathevan



View photos


County Court Chief Judge Peter Kidd explained why he chose to broadcast Pell's sentencing in an interview on The Project. Source: The Project/ 10 Network

Why does  any judge,let alone a chief judgeplain , need to appear on TV to explain his work,
 and in particular a matter which he says he cannot comment on?
And I thought 

What was Chief Judge Peter Kidd trying to achieve by appearing on TV, and that too on The Project which Gerrad Henderson describes as  " one of the media networks that led the pile-on against George Pell in the lead up to his trial and conviction"?

The Chief Judge needs to explain  himself.He chose to come down from the safety of the bench and into the public arena.


END 


See story on that interview by Yahoo News


'Maverick' judge who sentenced George Pell speaks out on The Project


The judge who presided over the landmark case of disgraced Cardinal George Pell has spoken out in a TV interview.

County Court Chief Judge Peter Kidd sentenced Pell to six years’ jail in March.

Mr Kidd, jokingly labelled a “maverick” judge by The Project host Waleed Ali, told the program in an interview on Tuesday night why he decided to have the sentencing aired live.

Pell raped one 13-year-old choirboy and sexually molested his friend in the sacristy of St Patrick's Cathedral in Melbourne in 1996 when he was newly-installed as Archbishop.

He molested the first boy again about a month later.

The trial was viewed around the world after Mr Kidd chose to broadcast Pell’s sentencing.

View photos

Disgraced Cardinal George Pell leaves the County Court of Victoria in February. Source: Getty ImagesMore

The Australian media could not report Pell’s convictions, despite being handed down in December, due to a suppression order until February.

“If they (the public) were to make a judgement about my particular sentence, which everybody is entitled to do as part of the democratic process, then it was important they heard those reasons in their entirety from me (and) not distorted or manipulated in any way by the commentators or politicians,” Mr Kidd told the program.

View photos

Waleed Aly interviewed County Court Chief Judge Peter Kidd has on The Project on Tuesday night. Source: The Project/ 10 NetworkMore

View photos

County Court Chief Judge Peter Kidd explained why he chose to broadcast Pell's sentencing in an interview on The Project. Source: The Project/ 10 NetworkMore

Mr Kidd added during his sentencing that Pell was not to be seen as a scapegoat for “perceived failings” of the Catholic church.

While he wouldn’t go into specifics surrounding Pell’s sentencing, Mr Kidd quashed any speculation high-profile figures ever receive preferential treatment when being sentenced.

“It’s not true that just because you’re a minister or the prime minister and you lose your job and you lose your status that you’re going to get a better outcome than someone else,” he said.

View photos

A man reacts as he watches a livestream of Pell being sentenced to jail time. Source: Getty ImagesMore

“In fact, the law grapples with this and says that’s exactly what the outcome shouldn’t be - you shouldn’t be simply rewarded because you’re a high-profile person.”

Pell won't be eligible for parole until he has served three years and eight months of his sentence.

- with AAP